11th Judicial Circuit Judge Rules In Favor Of City On Automated License Plate Readers

Ariel Fernandez

Founder & Editor
[email protected]


Judge Charles K. Johnson of the 11th Judicial Circuit of Florida has rendered a ruling from the bench in Raul Mas Canosa v. City of Coral Gables et al in favor of the defendants, the City of Coral Gables, Florida Department of State, Florida Secretary of State Ken Detzner, the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) and FDLE Commissioner Richard L. Swearingen. Judge Johnson made his ruling during a hearing on a Motion for Summary Judgement filed by the defendants on August 31st.

The Complaint

Raul Mas Canosa, a resident of the City, filed his suit in October of 2018 over the City’s use of Automated License Plate Readers. The images and data captured by the readers are saved by the City for a minimum of three years.

In his complaint, Mas Canosa argued that “the unlawful and invasive policies employed by the City of Coral Gables, under the auspices of the Florida Department of State and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, are likewise inimical to the rights of its citizens to be free from abusive governmental intrusion. Using dozens of automatic license plate recognition cameras and software, the City surreptitiously tracks, records, collects, and aggregates the personal and private activities of its citizens and visitors, without any prior suspicion of wrongdoing. It also stockpiles and analyzes this data for at least three years. Furthermore, it shares this data with a private vendor, who sells it to still other governmental entities. This complete surveillance cannot be countenanced by a 3 free society, and it violates the fundamental rights of every motorist who passes through the “City Beautiful.” (Read Full Complaint).

Mas Canosa is represented by the New Civil Liberties Alliance. In a case summary on their website, they further explain Mas Canosa’s concerns, “there are currently 30 ALPRs strategically placed at nearly every major artery in the city, including I-95, scanning and recording the license plate number of every vehicle that passes, capturing the registered owner and the time, date and location of the vehicle when it was captured. To date, this single system have collected tens of millions of license plate images.”

At the program’s onset, the City’s reasoning for archiving the data was to serve as a crime solving tool and would not be subject to public records requests by anyone other than the individual.

Reaction

“Yesterday’s ruling by Judge Charles Johnson has wide-ranging implications, as Automated License Plate Readers (ALPRs) are used as an effective law enforcement tool throughout the State of Florida.  In granting the City’s Motion for Summary Judgment, the Court found that the use of ALPRs does not violate the 4th Amendment to the United States Constitution or the “Right to Privacy” in the Florida Constitution.  The City is very pleased with the Court’s ruling and its continued ability to use this effective tool.” Miriam Soler Ramos, City Attorney

Mas Canosa stated that “the decision was disappointing, but not surprising.” He will appeal Johnson’s decision to the 3rd District Court of Appeals where the matter will be heard in front of a three judge panel.

Share:

7 thoughts on “11th Judicial Circuit Judge Rules In Favor Of City On Automated License Plate Readers

  1. Big Brother is always watching. Lovely society that we’ve created and sad that everyone accepts the intrusions.

  2. City needs to go further. Instead of simply recording plates, it would be wise to generate $$$ income from cameras. Why not fine speeders or people holding cell phones? Maybe fine speeders going 10 or 15 mph over the limit, without points, to make medicine more palatable? Truly immoral that we, including our politicians, do not implement cameras to ticket speeders! Truly immoral we permit drivers to have one hand on the steering wheel and the other on the phone! There’s Bluetooth. I guess the mobile companies, or their lobbyists, have control over the politicians. Or the politicians know their constituents, who are SELFISH and have no conscience, and are afraid of loosing their chairs. Maybe they want to generate additional income for the hospitals & funeral parlors?

  3. The City needs to have cameras on all intersections with traffic restrictions. As a resident of Coral Gables since 1980, I live & work in our City Beautiful. While driving back & forth to work, shopping, dining, etc. I see drivers violating restrictions on No Left Turn, No U Turn & No Right Turn on Red. Also a “new Parking style” I see cars & trucks parked against the flow of traffic. Is that “legal”?

  4. Anything that reduces crime is generally a good idea. I wish it did not come to this but our society today is extremely dangerous at every turn.

  5. The bipartisan cartel made general elections 2020 fraudulent by breached due process is not auditable among incumbent Trump v. Biden was to systematic bipartisan cartel to serve current monarchy federal coup that Speaker Pelosi & incumbent VP45 Pence & 435 Reps & 33 from 100 intentionally did on Jan 6, 2021 installed illegitimate 117th Congress to count 538 Electors votes appointed by 50 SOS who certified felony of those impersonate votes drop box mail felony did not victory for any candidate 2020. USA has to expel all usurpers being of fraudulent election 2020 to require US JCS Mil & Militias for call update news general election day by ID Voters cast your vote will only inside polls for suffrage. Or USA is already break up. 

  6. It’s dangerous an unaccountable federal Dr. Fauci already said it before, in fifteen days the summer begins ends its infectious virus aero bat bio-lab mutant only to infecting human was spread for support general election 2020 by method of impersonate vote drop box mail USPS felony did not victory to incumbent Trump v. Biden, for subversives 435 Reps & 100 Sens cover by its own 9 justice vitalize out 2/3 senate w/spy FISACourt, 13 Federal Courts Appeals filters on 50 Supreme Court State, to systematic subversive Speaker Pelosi & incumbent VP45 Pence installed illegitimated 117th Congress to count fraudulent votes 538 electors appointed by certificated of 50 SOS in line up its Governors. US 700K death murdered & US 99% infected forever. its vaccines misleading approved of emergency by FDA federal Nazi’s testing in pregnant a human crime did not immunize first, second doses & coming third shot it’s variant virus weaponry’s to attack only infected us. We must wear musk to save ourselves.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *