OPINION: How Many No’s Does It Take?

Dr. Karelia Martinez Carbonell, President Historic Preservation Association of Coral Gables

The community is saying NO. Residents are saying STOP. Constituents are saying ENOUGH.

Over 2000 residents to date have voiced their opinion against the Miracle Mile & Crafts Section rezoning through signed petitions, editorials, articles, letters, public comments, social media, etc. One resident recently opined in the Miami Herald, “I cannot name one person who lives in Coral Gables who supports this type of growth, however, it is happening before our eyes.”

Constituents speaking up on an issue should mean something to elected officials.  But DOES it? Will it?

Will the voice of the people make a difference on February 9th when the City Commission is scheduled to take a final vote on the up-zoning code changes to the historic Miracle Mile and Crafts Section? Yes. If residents have a say and they do. 

The pushback has its merits. Coral Gables hired the same zoning firm that created Miami 21 a decade ago.  Today, the City of Miami is tackling revisions to the code to “limit the massive and sometimes controversial [development] projects that have become flashpoints of community opposition” [Miami Herald June 14 2020]. 

In light of these issues, the Historic Preservation Association of Coral Gables has taken an official position requesting postponement of zoning changes affecting the future of Miracle Mile & Crafts Section. No need to rush this critical issue through.   




What was originally presented as a “clarification” to the zoning code has morphed into major changes—without offering residents an opportunity to participate in a public forum.

The City’s initial short press release published two years ago stated, “The City of Coral Gables Zoning Code, the main document that preserves the distinctive historic and architectural character of the municipality, is being updated to clarify, reorganize and streamline the regulations that determine the future of the city.”  Residents had no additional communication from the city until the item came up on first reading last October.

Subsequently, as it pertains to the Miracle Mile section, the goal [according to Ramon Trias, Coral Gables Assistant Director for Planning] was to “Encourage residents above shops. Enhance pedestrian experience.” In other words, revitalize the Mile by residential decree.  However, according to the current mayor, “Throughout the years there have been many attempts to help rebrand and improve the Mile … We saw a small improvement when the former bus depot was redeveloped into a mixed-used building with residential apartments but it is not enough.”

So what is enough to improve the Mile? The best proven way to enhance the “pedestrian experience” is to strategically steward the historic nature of Miracle Mile and its surroundings by developing its retail strategy to include the area’s heritage as an economic asset.  Studies support that historic districts outperform the market as a whole.  And Miracle Mile can thrive if its heritage is preserved and promoted.

Presently, there are close to 2200 residences within close proximity of Miracle Mile.  The premise that people have to live on Miracle Mile to shop on the Mile is flawed if one believes the marketing materials used to draw people to live off the Mile.  One example states, “A great opportunity to live in the center and heart of Coral Gables … Conveniently located within walking distance to Miracle Mile” or “Located in the historic and well-known shopping district of Coral Gables, Florida called “Miracle Mile”. It is walking distance to countless restaurants, cafes, shops, and bars. This “walker’s paradise” offers residents true convenience.”  

More density is not the answer.  More “residents above the shops” will not increase the shopping but a place’s heritage will.  Economic vitality in historic districts is supported by research. The rate of value increase in historic districts outperforms the market as a whole. 

The $25 million streetscape project ignored the historic character of the area. It did not draw economic relief so heralded. Neither will a zoning change.  

The local community strongly voices its concern over the potential irreparable damage to the historic character of the downtown and thus the continued economic decline of the area.  

With all due respect Commissioners, listen to your constituents. They may know best.

 [Recognition goes to a very dedicated HPACG volunteer for the research used in this article.]


10 thoughts on “OPINION: How Many No’s Does It Take?

  1. GC should change its motto from “City Beautiful” to “Come and Build Your High Rise Here”. We seem to spend a lot of money trying to be whom we are not. How much money was spent on redoing MM where the sidewalks now look dirty, outdoor seating lies empty under the brutal sun, and parallel parking has done nothing more than make it only more difficult to shop there. What about the gimmicky expensive art like the painting of the crosswalk in front of City Hall, the purple sculpture, the little clouds with messages on lampposts, the Giralda Umbrella project ; and, let’s not forget Audrey the Man Eating Plant on Segovia and Biltmore Way. How have these enhanced the quality of life in CG or drawn people in?. Now under the guise of “tweaking” Zoning Rules, they happen to include a little-known-to-the-public Redevelopment of MM and without garages? I suppose to imprison people to shop there. Do we want more cementing of the core of CG beyond Ponce Plaza? Is all of this going to turn GC into a walkable City? Try walking from Biltmore Way to MM in midday with no shade. How has CG moved from being an admired resident-centered City to the epicenter of Miami Dade real estate developments?

  2. More density is not the answer. Each day Coral Gables gets farther from being a “walker’s paradise” due to lack of enforcement of laws and ordinances. Signs through Miracle Mile and Ponce de Leon say bikes and scooters are forbidden in sidewalks yet they are there all the time as a menace to pedestrians. Speeding cars and cars that do not stop on designated crosswalks for pedestrians on intersections go about without any law enforcement. And you have to do something about the shops, help make them more attractive and not relics of another era with unattractive merchandise and decor. Of course there are very fine examples of beautiful stores and nice restaurants in Miracle Mile and more like those should be encouraged. People will go to a place not because they live there, but because it is safe, attractive —well kept historic districts do attract people— and with multiple offerings.

  3. Parallel reference; I was raised in Miami Shenandoha’s original section which was founded and most homes built in the 1920’s by the Merick family. The city of Miami has ignored and neglected this area for decades. Even prominent city commissioners that rose to greater power turned a blind eye in favor of Miami 21 code, familiar connections with developers and out right lack of an original thought.

    What is needed is better business development in the area. A thoughtful approach to attracting the “right mix” of businesses. Form a commission to approve and review new business with novel concepts or that show great potential by providing them starter reductions in rent or work with local business talent at University of Miami’s Business School. The city of CG directly manages many of the shuttered businesses on the mile and/or can influence the current landlords to incubate new businesses rather than leave these store fronts empty for sometime years. Let’s be very clear the only benefit of a vacant property is as a tax loophole. Options are available however it will require a government that is not aligned with developers, but rather residents.

  4. Well written. Will they finally hear us, remains the question. I suggest we, the residents, meet up in front of city hall February 9th and and make sure our voices are heard, loud and clear!!

  5. I’m originally from Mexico, and moved to the states because I was fed up of politicians doing whatever they wanted without listening to their constituents, how come the same is happening now?

  6. No STOP Enough to the Miracle Mile rezoning.
    Additionally, stop so many buildings in the area of Merrick Park and add a park instead to maintain the city beautiful.
    More green and less cement is beautiful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *